While reading chapters 10 and 11, Melville uses the shared room between Ishmael and Queequeg as a space where they can act without judgment, and as a place where companionship transcends into romance. In chapter 10, Melville writes “Man and wife, they say, there open the very bottom of their souls to each other; and some old couples often lie and chat over old times till nearly morning. Thus, then, in our hearts’ honeymoon, lay I and Queequeg— a cosy, loving pair” (Melville 58). Here, Ishmael compares his and Queequeg’s relationship to a couple, saying that couples can chat till the morning and enjoy each other’s company. Ishmael is now getting used to Queequeg and even enjoys his company, so much to the point of romantic feelings. The “romance” between the two men can also be seen in chapter 11. Melville writes on page 59, “Queequeg now and then affectionately throwing his brown tattooed legs over mine…” and “…so entirely sociable and free and easy were we”. In their room, where it’s just them two, they can do whatever they want without judgment. They are able to live freely- like a couple does. Queequeg is growing on Ishmael, and their relationship is very romantic. They are not only sleeping with each other but they are cuddling with each other. Ishmael feels so close to Queequeg that he feels “free” in their shared room.
Another thing I want to add is, I feel Melville included the relationship between Ishmael and Queequeg as a way to explore his own sexuality and his relationship with Nathaniel Hawthorne. From week 4’s slides, it seems like Hawthorne and Melville had a serious relationship. And on page 57, Ishmael says he ”began to be sensible of strange feelings.” And also goes on to say he “began to feel myself mysteriously drawn towards him.” This magnetic pull towards Queequeg is making Ishmael confused, and this can be seen as a reflection for Melville being confused about his own sexuality. One thing for certain is, this most definitely can be seen as Ishamel questioning his sexuality and his feelings for his roommate- Queequeg.
Good points here about how the novel makes us see the intimate relationship between the men. I would like to see you push towards WHY a bit more, while staying with the text– rather than jumping to biographical speculation about the author. What is at stake in this depiction that you develop? keep going. Good work!
To start—I absolutely adored your intriguing introduction title, it immediately made me gravitate towards your post. The relationship dynamic between these two characters is so interesting, especially in the romantic aspect. Considering the time period and culture of this society, having this sort of intimate relationship between contrasting people with opposing morals and seeing how their interactions change positively over time—shows the connectivity between all people. I also really like how it isn’t just a basic friendship, nut something more, something that could be considered taboo, but they do it anyways. These whalers blatant disregard to societal norms is the perfect rebellious spirit for life on the sea.
Hi Francisca! I love that you connected the exploration of romantic feelings that Ishmael is experiencing with Queequeg, with what Melville was experiencing during the writing process. Knowing about his relationship with Hawthorne made these chapters feel even more intimate, almost like reading a diary