To preface this, I’m a librarian. I struggle a lot with annotating my novels, especially ones that I hold dear, because I worry that they will cause them to fall apart faster. Moby-Dick has somewhat proven this to be true, as I have already had to use Book Tape to secure the cover in place, but it’s also really shown how much the novel itself has affected me and the ways that it’s changed my engagement with novels. I think another thing to note is that I’ve changed this copy as much as it has changed me.

I bought a second copy for my final project and decided to use it as a direct comparison to my own copy. The left copy was purchased new at the beginning of the semester. The right copy was found second-hand but in good condition. From the way that they look, I would have assumed the opposite prior to owning them.

While not super apparent in this photo, the copy with the annotations, pictured on the bottom, actually stands a little taller than the fresh copy – as though my own interpretations have caused the very pages to swell with new meaning.


Through this class, I’ve fully grown comfortable with annotating as a means of better understanding and taking the time to slow down with a novel. My annotations started as simple personal notes – haha, oh wow, etc – and evolved into ways to track the sections we mentioned during class that I may have missed, sections that struck me as full of depth, notes on the historical context, as well as questions that I want to ask myself on later reads. My annotations have become a roadmap for close reading the novel, with the tabs marking most (I ran out of tabs twice) of the annotations throughout the book.
Hi Kit!
My brother is also a librarian, and he almost has a stroke every time he sees any of my classics because they’re so annotated and destroyed (I call it well-loved). I love it when you mentioned how you ran out of tabs twice, because that’s EXACTLY why my copy of “Moby Dick” has three different-colored tabs. I tried to be aesthetic, but the book was too big for consistency…
Hi Kit,
I love that you are thinking not just of the effect that the book has had on you but the effect that you’ve had on your physical copy. I think it will be an interesting way to observe yourself and your own growth throughout this first read. I imagine that you will have so much more to learn from your annotations when you decide to revisit the book.
This is a great reflection post– and love the comments on it too!