I really found chapter 35 interesting because there were several allusions to the conscious and unconscious that Ishmael channels from when explaining the experience of the mast with the high winds. In consciousness, he realizes that, and to paraphrase, uneventfulness is witnessed when there is no news, or extras’, indicating entertainment and consumerism that feeds off of people’s souls. There is one particular text he says, which is: “…it is much deplored that the place which you devote so considerable a portion of…your natural life, should be so sadly destitute of anything approaching to a cosy inhabitiveness… a comfortable localness of feeling…a bed, a hammock, a hearse, a sentry box, a pulpit….” This text in particular is critical because it challenges artificial, man-made transcendence through these mediums of vanity and how we as humans are wired to find comfort in sedentary life fascinated by consumerism. In this way, the author warns us that we become too comfortable to actually be our full potential as we isolate and hide in these mediums for comfort. ‘Cosy inhabitiveness’ contradicts itself as both words are nothing alike, juxtaposing themselves and working against. This is written into the line in order to convey “otherness” to the medium, making readers realize that the comfort we often resort to in society is almost always consumed in media to make us feel elated and transcended. By doing so, we do ourselves the disservice of breaking free from toxic consumerism/ advertisements telling people how to live their lives in order to gain money out of people’s worldviews. This becomes dangerous as we breath in media and make it a social propaganda that divides instead of reframes conceptual ideas and infrastructure.
Author Archives: Arabelle Abrajano
Week 7: Ishmael’s accounts as a victim under capitalism
In chapter 25, Ishmael sounds like he has had enough with how people view workers in the whale industry. By using analogy of whalers as significant roles that generate society, he also gets caught up in not seeing how he unintentionally sabotages their role by indirectly subjecting their role for the sole lives of the upper class. He states that, “It is well known that at the coronation of kings and queens, even modern ones, a certain curious process of seasoning them for their functions is gone through…Can it be…that they anoint it with a view of making its interior run well, as they anoint their machinery?… As a general rule, he can’t amount to much in his totality”(Melville 123). These lines resonate with my last blog post on the etymology and extracts of the novel–discussing whales as something more than objects under capitalism, but animals that are cleverly invested under the nation– because as Ishmael tries to not ‘lay his treasures on earth’ as captain Peleg does, there is the unfortunate tragedy hidden in these chapters where he still tries to define his individuality under earthly status and approval of nobility. The next chapters–26 and 27– provide more insight into the sailors, almost dictating them under pawn status of the king. ‘Seasoning them for their designated functions’ adds to the sailor’s pawn role, subjecting them to merely surpress their emotions and complexities as humans in order to guarantee whaling success out in the seas. The chapters expose how their past trials and tribulations desensitized their emotions, reverting back to how the text also “anoints machinery with oil”, interestingly connecting to how the men on the ship become machinery that is already used to the difficult circumstances on the ship.
Week 6: Recording and Processing Information through the Ego
From reading chapters 4-12, Ishmael’s affection for his roommate, Queepeg, grows strong because of his oddities and peculiarities that are not touched by societal conventions. In addition, his touch makes Ishmael question his identity and things from his past with his stepmother, yearning for reciprocation that he never had in terms of maternal care. It is interesting that Melville writes “stepmother”, emphasizing maternal care that is seemingly not real for the character, making us readers to also diagnose his freudian condition.
While Melville sets us up as behaviorial therapists, the book makes it clear that Ishmael registers information through the ego– through symbols he knows in his life to be true, but now reevaluates those same symbols. This egocentric mindset he has is present when othering Queepeg and the ways he carries himself.”He was just enough civilized to show off his outlandishness in the strangest possible manner”(Melville 31). Here, Ishmael senses that the way he operates is based outside the symbols and body languages he is often used to seeing, increasing his affinity for the unconventional Queepeg displays outwardly. Showing off his outlandishness in an odd way alludes to how Ishmael is secretly obsessed with wanting to break through the barrier of conventional he functions in, understanding that Queepeg is intelligent, but also a calculated cannibal. Ishmael’s secret obsession with Queepeg is instigated further when he attempts to other him through the same misunderstanding tone he conveys in the last text above. When reading the room, Ishmael notes: “Queepeg sat there…, it so chanced… To be sure I cannot say much for his breeding…(Melville 34)” This particular tone in the text is dehumanizing, but exposes how vulnerable Ishmael is about Queepeg’s presence. In a sense, it could be projection because Ishmael knows he is walking into danger with a powerful yet odd being. The imagery of them as roommates and Ishmael developing some unresolved feelings, with the fact that Queepeg is revealed as calculated paints the picture of who really is the prey being dehumanized as someone powerless. Besides Ishmael’s liking for Queepeg and their dynamic present in the book, the chapter names kind of sound like we are operating in Ishamel’s mind throughout the course of the events. At one point, the names go from “Breakfast” to “Street” to “Chapel”, and so on, as if we are moving along in his perspective, recording and capturing events. This type of perspective really emphasizes how we operate through common symbols and language, pointing out striking strange things in our line of sight throughout the day.
Week 5: Significance of humanity and whaling
I really enjoyed reading a brief intro of how the etymology and extracts became a part of the book through librarian research. In this perspective, rather than another notable figure or author, it gives the book a whole new meaning of what whaling was for the common people and the nation itself. Two separate quotes from the etymology and extracts that I found interesting was the intro to etymology and one of the extracted quotes. It is interesting to see how we as humans give importance to literary or figurative symbols in society. We inevitably interact with the symbols around us and maintain that with responsibility and care throughout time. The intro states that, “He loved to dust his old grammars; it somehow reminded him of his mortality.(Melville)” This quote illustrates how symbols have such an imprinted impact into our minds that we are reminded of our humanity, which I think the whole book argues is our greatest strength to acknowledge. To add to that, an extract quote states that, “…they saw many whales sporting in the ocean, and in the wantonness fuzzing up the water through their pipes and vents, which nature has placed on their shoulders.(Melville 43)” This emphasizes to the earlier statement so much more because, in our realization of how small we are, our humanity still plays a role in advancing and reflecting on the significance of whales as these intelligent yet dangerous beings that are marveled from terrestrial view. The quote’s word choice and usage is also an important aspect to look into, indirectly describing these whales as an essential mode in the seas. Our capitalization and use of these whales then in turn magnify the nation as an infrastructure that cleverly invests rather than fully dominate the whales or subject them to merely animals. When seeing the animals in this sort of light, the state has recognition for the responsibility to use the whale’s responsibility for good– whatever good meant or benefitted at that time. On the contrary, the last part of the sentence sounded as if it was social propaganda to spark the generative progression of revitalized working class people at that time. The vivid imagery of machinery being on the responsibility of the people to manage the nature around them paints the picture of human labor as “natural”. In that case, humanity is our strength, but can be manipulated for weakness and submission.
Week 4: Advancing Our Knowledge of the Sea= a revert back to the superficial?
While rereading the article on the Blue Humanities, I kept thinking how when a society advances we become self-reliant and dependent. In addition, Steve Mentz’s “A poetics of planetary water” solidifies the idea that the sea should be a meditative condition, not necessarily something to believe by sight. The sea as a form of the unknown and unconventional would diminish in value, being purely for aesthetic and commercial appeal if its knowledge becomes easily reproducible. Gillis states that “Until the nineteenth century, notes writer James Hamilton-Paterson,”… our understanding of the sea was “literally superficial, . . . a navigable surface, obviously, above an abyss.(Gillis)” In this instance, the sea was a superficial symbol to status because we had less information about the sea to even acknowledge its significance. The article illustrates the depth to how much information we hold in digital and real time, but with that power, the aesthetic of the sea repeats itself as it becomes recycled and reproduced overtime. With this in mind, Mentz also suggests that water is everywhere– as a solid liquid, and gas– but, it is something we feel the most: “Water changes appear intimately and tangibly. We feel them on our skin(Mentz 144-145).” Consequentially, would already knowing the sea mean we have the advantage to dismiss subjectivity and prioritize Western principle in institutions as beforehand during the Industrial era? In modern day, it can be witnessed digitally without any thought of its significance. I guess there is no real concern besides the sea becoming less anticipated and groundbreaking as before, but one can only speculate how the symbol of the sea becomes marketable– in a good or bad way? In a way, planetary water is restricted for the elite knowledge and the sea as a symbol of hope for marginalized communities becomes a medium to manipulate the less privileged.
For a summer class, I studied anthropology and how literature keeps the area of study alive with its material culture. While the sea is a body of water that cannot be analyzed all at once, one notable thing stood out to me in the class, which is: the anticipation of fiction, with maritime curiosity, helps us prepare for events that are unexpected and out of the ordinary. I think there are pros and cons into regulating and advancing the information of the sea, but it depends on how it is viewed as in society’s grapple. With this in mind, I am interested to see how we then prepare for this advancement of knowing the seas and how we preserve maritime literature for future generations.
Week 3: Reclamation of the Blue Humanities
From reading both articles, I now understand that Moby Dick is an extensive novel that exposes human greed. In other words, we categorize and label experiences based on our implicit biases and pride, whether we like to accept this factual statement or not. I feel that there is a working between outside events and subjective intake that has plagued the working class of the 19th century, because we cannot accept ideologies apart from Western ideology or societal principle.
The Blue Humanities article talks about how the symbolic features of the sea can be inadvertently used to justify uplifted status in the terrestrial land. ” It became a symbol of eternity, a comfort to those who, having lost their faith in divine dispensation of everlasting life, came to see in its apparently timeless flows evidence of nature’s immortality and a secular promise of life everlasting.(Gillis)” While this is indicative that there is co-existence that is present with the sea, the symbol of nature and the sea as “transcendent” bleeds into the human supremacy of the privileged groups on land. In a way, this metaphor for life and living becomes a danger for those unprivileged and marginalized groups in land. Consequentially, I think that Melville uses Moby Dick to call out the symbol within the Industrial Age.
On the contrary, the symbol of the sea works to articulate the invisible power of marginalized communities during the Industrial age, and gives a platform for those voices. Even though the experimental novel works to examine the romantic senses that is excessively capitalized in the Industrial Age, its spiritual symbol is so authentic to human culture, surpassing elite status or upper class society within the terrestrial land hierarchy. For example, the symbol is reflective of our behavior and brings back the sentiment of human contentedness and hope when comparing our labor to the immense infrastructure of the sea and what we don’t know.
Week 2: Emerson and King
The marvel of human transcendentalism in Emerson’s work, “The American Scholar”, is challenged by the real catastrophe of the Essex, as themes of contention and circumstances that are out of man’s control is tested by nature. Melville’s accounts of Pallard’s biography and general real life occurrences are what he argues to be the major instigator for what and who has the reigns of freewill and power in society. It is not as easy as it seems to be in align with one’s morals when tribulations such as starvation and isolation mode enter the human survival phase. An article by Smithsonian gives light to the causes of the Essex event, indicating that the madness ensued made men lose their morals: “Humanity must shudder at the dreadful recital” of what came next, … They then roasted the man’s organs on a flat stone and ate them.”(King) This sorrowful account experienced by the vulnerable men on the ship alludes to how men cannot fully triumph over nature or predict the future in an immediate notice. The sad reality is that we as humans are inevitably subject to this defeat of vulnerability that has plagued many minority group’s conditional state in light of general corrupt leadership. As Emerson believes us to be able to rise above the past, we are still fated to the past; in a larger sense, we are still fated to become mere machines to capitalism that tears down our sense of individuality.
In addition, I find it fascinating that the connection of a hunger for knowledge outside being a machine in capitalism can overlap with the physical, literal senses of hunger as accounted during the Essex event. Emerson states that, “…when the intervals of darkness come, as come they must,–when the sun is hid, and the stars withdraw their shining, –we repair to the lamps which were kindled by their ray, to guide our steps to the East again, where the dawn is…. The Arabian proverb says, “A fig tree, looking on a fig tree, becometh fruitful.”(Emerson) Here, Emerson explains that, because we should become advocates for our individuality in light of capitalism and collective thinking, we can learn from our close relational peers towards a utopian society. However, Melville’s novel alludes to how this educational feat can become a danger when outside circumstances and factors arise. While Emerson strives lifting each other up in, there is a grotesque underlying of “feeding” that literally eats one’s individuality away into the subjectivity of human pleasure. It might be a reach, but I feel that this imagery of eating has some great part(and potential) in the discussion regarding human transcendentalism in concern with dealing with our fleshly desires.
Intro

(Left: me Right: my friend) 🙂
Hi class!
my name is Arabelle, and this will be my last year at state. I am majoring in English and Comparative Literature, and am very excited to start grad school some time in the future! I enjoy my time reading on the beach with friends, hiking some of the trails here at san diego! One major thing I would love to do after graduation is visit the Philippines, along with Thailand and other Southeast Asian countries during the summer. I really enjoy hiking, so I am very adamant that my friends and family start day one in the Chocolate Hills in Northern Luzon! Besides future excursions and activities, I try to help my mom with the donation and charities back at her hometown in Cebu. So far, we have washed and folded as many clothes in boxes to ship overseas. With that, I love being organized and thrifty with my money so I try to do my own diy bangs at home, which I am in the process of growing back again. Excited to learn about the material in class and getting to know all of you!