I consider The Forge to be an extremely sad chapter, mainly because my favorite person, Ahab, sounds particularly sad in this chapter. The passage states, “This done, and Ahab moodily stalked away with the weapon; the sound of his ivory leg, and the sound of the hickory pole, both hollowing ringing along every plank. But ere he entered his cabin, a light, unnatural, half-bantering, yet most piteous sound was heard. Oh, Pip! thy wretched laugh, thy idle but unresting eye; all thy strange mummeries not unmeaningly blended with the black tragedy of the melancholy ship, and mocked it!” (Melville 533). I really like this passage because Melville is using sound to describe the current state of the whole ship. He uses the word ‘hollow’ particularly because the ship feels empty and dark, especially with Ahab’s presence; this adds more meaning to the term, of how Ahab’s mood has been affecting the ship this entire time. The Pequod represents a mass of emptiness, a void where silence brought loneliness into Ahab. The reason why I believe Ahab feels lonely is that he has been distancing himself for quite some time. There is a difference between him and the crew, a social hierarchy where Ahab is on top of it, and the crew is at the very bottom. This explains the distance between them because they could never fit in a different environment when they are already in their own comfort zone. But then Pip’s ‘piteous’ laugh came in, his laugh acts as a reminder to Ahab that he is not alone, and there will always be people around him, whether he accepts them or not. You guys are probably wondering: Why is Pip’s laugh important? This is because Ahab considers this ship to be melancholy, empty, and dark. It reminded Ahab of the memories when he first became a whaleman, and Pip’s pitiful laugh possibly balances out the creepy vibes that the ship is having. His laugh mocked everything that this ship stands for, and Ahab loves it.
I learned so much about you from this blog post! First, I’m so curious why Ahab is your favorite character!And second, I think you’re right to see his connection to Pip and Pip’s laughter as being pivotal– it is full of possibility for wrenching Ahab from his melancholy. The fact that Ahab does not want to be taken out of the state of melancholy, and thus silences Pip’s laughter, suggests that there might be possibilities other than his dedicated sadness and monomaniacal plan, right? In other words, this is an important moment in the novel because it’s the first time wherein we get a sense that Ahab realizes that he is choosing doom. Pip is a kind of lifeline that Ahab refuses.
Hi Mylo!
Enjoyed reading your post so much! I like that you pointed out the choice of words Melville used when describing the hollowness Ahab is feeling and how lonely and dark it is for him. I have noticed that Melville has used darkness and loneliness in other chapters when talking about the feelings of these men on the ship. It makes me think about how the discussion of depression and solemness is not really talked about directly but more so discreetly, through the use of light and darkness. I can only imagine how lonely it must feel on the ship regardless of the other men who you have no connection to, besides the job in front of you.