In Chapter 35, Ishmael is standing on the mast-head to keep lookout while admitting that “…I kept but sorry guard”(171) because he is too emerged into his thoughts. Reflecting back on early class discussions regarding the type of services the ocean provided for people— travel and a form of clarity, Melville demonstrates the impact the ocean has on Ishmael by diverting his attention from the job in front of him to being drowned in a state of reflection while simultaneously being distracted.
During this state of mind, Ishmael reflects on the young philosophers who lack interest and ambition while whaling and then continues to emphasize the importance of not been distracted while observing “But while this sleep, this dream is on ye, move your foot or hand an inch, slip your hold at all; and your identity comes back in horror.”(173) Ishmael seems to realize the influence he has on his own life—the delicacy of life while on the boat.
Your close readings are getting better, but I would like to still see you push your ideas further. You write,”Melville demonstrates the impact the ocean has on Ishmael by diverting his attention from the job in front of him to being drowned in a state of reflection while simultaneously being distracted.” So why is this important? What is reflection and distraction, are they different? What does this scene say about these states of being or about their importance?
Hi Jackie!
I really like your description of Ismael being “drowned in a state of reflection while simultaneously being distracted.” Firstly, I love the water based language of “drowned.” Secondly, I think your point really touches on our previous class discussion on how Melville presents a direct contradiction of things throughout his novel (ex. “ungodly” and “godlike”). Like you describe, Ismael is both drowned in reflection, yet wholly distracted by it.
Hello Jackie,
I found this chapter interesting. The fact that Ishmael cannot be a good watch because he is too distracted by the ocean goes to show the distraction and therapy the ocean can provide. The calmness of the waves is making him forget his reality, especially since he is isolated from everyone else. I also like how you use the oceanic-term “drowned” when talking about the ocean and Ishmael’s thoughts.
Great post!
You did a great job connecting Ishmael’s daydreaming to the ocean’s reflective power and danger. I like how you highlighted that balance between thought and survival, it really captures Melville’s warning about losing oneself at sea.