Reflection on Moby Dick

This class has been a huge learning experience for me that I would do again. I initially took this class because I saw Moby Dick as an important/constantly mentioned in pop culture and I wanted to see what it was all about. I am also ambitious and wanted to tell people I have read this book. Once class began, and the reading did too, I started to feel challenged by the ‘so-what’ push we have gotten all semester. I am used to reading something and liking it for aesthetic purposes, but I rarely questioned a line in a book and asked why it is important. This forced me to consider what I am reading in a larger context/include my own personal experience. But as the semester went on I really enjoyed making connections to the real world from a 1 or 2 sentence line, it forced me to think really deeply about single words.

Another thing that stands out to me is the class discussions that we would have. This would be an initial point of insecurity in the beginning of the class, I took it as an indicator that I was not ‘understanding’ the book in the same way other people did. But this was another thing that I had to shift my thinking about. These discussions pointed out so many amazing parts of this book that would reshape the way I initially read some parts. The sharing of interpretation was also helpful when I was genuinely confused in certain chapters. Overall I really liked taking this class and it taught me new ways to approach reading, thinking about literature and about feeling lost/confused when reading a book.

Week 16 – Final Takeaways/So What?

This class has definitely been a roller-coaster, yet one I have enjoyed every step of the way. Not only did this class enable me to further develop my skills in close-reading and reignite the fun of annotating books, but it has also helped my to read between the lines of a story. Not everything that makes Moby Dick what it is is stated outright in the novel, and yet, thanks to group discussions, everything seems so clear.

My final take away from Moby Dick and the class as a whole is the importance of interpretation and perspective. We are all approaching the novel from different angles, different backgrounds, forms of education, and the newest historical perspective. All of these factors are important as they shape the way an individual close reads a novel, whether having read it before or not, and what they might be drawn to within the book itself. Many of the parts I found extremely boring within the novel and left mostly unannotated were caked in notes and further developed in group discussions by others. It has made me value the importance of every interpretation, whether it be a scholarly critic or my classmate across the room. These different interpretations allow for different analysis of a specific text, creating a different approach to literary development and rhetorical analysis from not only an academic approach, but a cultural one as well. We have experienced a life that never before could have been imagined by people in the 1850s, and yet for the most part, the ideals that Herman Melville portrayed in his novel still have important relevance to all of us in 2025.

Learning to See the Light in Moby Dick

As the semester comes to an end, I’ve been thinking back about how this class changed the way I read Moby-Dick, but also how I read literature in general. When we started, the novel felt overwhelming to me because it was too big, too strange, too full of digressions about whales and ropes and blubber to make any sense. But somewhere along the way, I think through our weekly blog posts and close-reading exercises, I started to see that Moby-Dick isn’t a book you “get” in one go. It’s a book that teaches you how to read it as you move through it. And that process of learning to slow down, to focus on a single sentence, even a comma, ended up being one of the most valuable things I’m taking from the course.

One of the biggest skills I developed this semester was close reading. Before this class, I understood the concept in theory, but actually practicing it every week forced me to go beyond surface-level interpretation. I am (still) learning how to zoom in on a phrase and unpack it until it opens into a whole world of meaning. Whether I was analyzing Starbuck’s desperate moments or Ishmael’s reflection that the whaleman “lives in light” in Chapter 97, I realized that Melville’s writing rewards slow attention. The more I practiced explication, the more I started noticing how Melville builds entire ideas out of tiny details: the way the color white becomes terrifying, the way light turns both holy and hellish, and the way the ocean becomes a metaphor for the unknown parts of ourselves.

A huge part of that shift came from how this class framed Moby-Dick within Blue Humanities. I had never thought about literature through an oceanic perspective before, and Blue Humanities helped me see how Melville uses the ocean to rethink what it means to be human. Instead of centering land, stability, and certainty, he places us in water: fluid, unpredictable, and unknowable. The ocean in Moby-Dick becomes a space of connection and vulnerability. Seeing the novel through this lens made me appreciate the environmental undertones, too. When Ishmael describes the killing, boiling, and rendering of whales in such detailed but industrial language, it becomes impossible not to think about ecological violence and the human hunger for mastery over it. Blue Humanities gave me a way to understand these sections not as digressions, but as essential parts of the novel’s argument about power, exploitation, and the actual cost of human progress.

Thinking back on the blog posts we wrote throughout the semester makes me realize how much my relationship to the novel has changed. At first, I was kind of confused but interested, not fully sure how to approach such a massive, chaotic text. But each post forced me to commit to something specific. That practice taught me that meaning doesn’t come from “finishing” the book; it comes from engaging with the tiny details that build it. By the time we reached the final chapters, I wasn’t intimidated by Melville’s style anymore. Whether Melville is describing the ocean as a mirror of human consciousness or showing the consequences of obsession through Ahab, the book constantly asks us to look inward and outward at the same time. What I learned in this class goes far beyond Moby-Dick itself. I learned how to slow down, trust my observations, and use textual evidence to build ideas instead of relying on summaries or generalizations. I learned how to treat literature as something alive, something that reveals new meanings depending on where you point your attention.

Week 16: Final Takeaways

This semester really flew by, and even though Moby Dick was such a long book, it seems not so long ago that we opened those first pages, ignorant to what would occur between the cover and the back. I really enjoyed getting back into the practice of close reading this semester. There were so many parts of the book I would have skipped over or not found relevant, but the structure of the class and discussion based part of the class allowed for me to see and explore parts of the book that I wouldn’t have on my own. I doubt I would’ve had the patience or motivation to read Moby Dick on my own, so reading it in a class and alongside others was helpful. I also really enjoyed hearing other people’s interpretations, and seeing how different backgrounds influenced people’s interpretations. 

This was an important book for me to read because, like many others, I have heard this novel classified as a great American book, a story of adventure, of hunting animals. And before this class, I accepted that as what the book was about. However, reading this book, and considering the historical and social contexts surrounding it, changed this idea for me. I am not sure what this novel is exactly, but understanding how these ideas of classic, adventure, canon are formed was important to me. It brings up the question of how any idea of anything important is formed and how and why we attribute value to the things we do. I think this is in part due to Dr. Pressman’s teaching style, since I felt the last class I took with her also prompted many questions in myself about how the world is formed and how little understanding we have of the things we think we understand as a society or within scientific domains.

Emoji-Dick, Coming to you now In Color!

Hey everyone,

I wasn’t sure if I was the only one struggling to read Emoji-Dick in black and white, but I found a complete PDF in color for your viewing pleasure. I double checked and made sure that y’all should be able to access the link.

I hope it helps!

-Kit Jackson

Final Project Proposal

For my final project, I will be doing a 6-8 page essay that further expands on my essay 2. I will be focusing on how Melville uses Ahab to highlight what an unhealthy obsession looks like and how it can lead them to madness. I will be specifically close reading chapter 113, The Forge and how Ahab’s forged harpoon is used to represent his madness.

Annotating the inner brow

To preface this, I’m a librarian. I struggle a lot with annotating my novels, especially ones that I hold dear, because I worry that they will cause them to fall apart faster. Moby-Dick has somewhat proven this to be true, as I have already had to use Book Tape to secure the cover in place, but it’s also really shown how much the novel itself has affected me and the ways that it’s changed my engagement with novels. I think another thing to note is that I’ve changed this copy as much as it has changed me.

I bought a second copy for my final project and decided to use it as a direct comparison to my own copy. The left copy was purchased new at the beginning of the semester. The right copy was found second-hand but in good condition. From the way that they look, I would have assumed the opposite prior to owning them.

While not super apparent in this photo, the copy with the annotations, pictured on the bottom, actually stands a little taller than the fresh copy – as though my own interpretations have caused the very pages to swell with new meaning.

Through this class, I’ve fully grown comfortable with annotating as a means of better understanding and taking the time to slow down with a novel. My annotations started as simple personal notes – haha, oh wow, etc – and evolved into ways to track the sections we mentioned during class that I may have missed, sections that struck me as full of depth, notes on the historical context, as well as questions that I want to ask myself on later reads. My annotations have become a roadmap for close reading the novel, with the tabs marking most (I ran out of tabs twice) of the annotations throughout the book.

Final Project Proposal

For my final project, I think I have finally decided on utilizing my second close reading essay and expanding on the themes and ideas of complicity that exist throughout the novel. My argument is going to revolve around the way in which Melville presents complicity through the characters and how he uses it in a way that is so representative of the complicity that resides within the American population.

At the moment, I think I am going to just be writing a 6 – 8 page essay, however, I really do want to do something creative so if inspiration hits me that might completely change.

Final Project Proposal

For this final project, I really want to focus on the theme of whiteness because Melville has such a fascinating way of describing it, and I will be utilizing my second essay to its fullest extent by exploring this topic. However, one particular point I am currently stuck on is creativity.  I have this desire to be as creative as possible, but my mind is giving me blank answers. I would love to make a creative project that relates to its theme. I am working on how to make an artwork that revolves around the thesis statement, and I will be trying my best to finish it by the end of next week. 

Final Project Proposal

Final Project Proposal: I really want to elaborate on my second essay about illumination and how Melville uses whale oil and whalers to reflect on the actual cost of what humans are doing. The contradictions between whalers bringing the light to society while living and acting in the darkness. The whalemen are shown to be both creators and destroyers, and Melville shows quite clearly (ironically enough) that the line between these two is often quite blurry and hard to distinguish.

My thesis is going to argue that a whaleman’s very “life of light” is both his glory and his doom, always tied closely together. I will show this not only through the actual content of the novel but also through the physical grammar and syntax that Melville chooses to use through its structure and rhythm. “What begins as just a factual observation about whale oil, which happens to be the literal “food of light,” expands into a moral and metaphysical reflection on the cost of illumination itself. Melville’s language transforms physical light into a spiritual metaphor, complicating the whaleman’s apparent purity by revealing the violence and destruction that make such light possible in the first place.” 

Through this creative project I will be demonstrating this argument in an expanded essay of at least 6-8 pages with multiple sources such as Steve Mentz’ articles on the study of blue humanities. I chose this format because it gives me enough space to trace Melville’s symbolic patterns and connect them to broader environmental and ethical questions.